There is a certain breed of pop song that creeps in through the back door, kicks off its slippers and refuses to leave. “Earrings” by Malcolm Todd is one of them. It sat quietly at the head of a 2024 mixtape, two and a half minutes of wobbly keyboards and bedroom-pop shrugging, until the internet noticed it two years later and promptly lost its collective marbles. The premise is almost comically small: a man leaves a pair of earrings in somebody’s bed and can’t summon the nerve to mention it. Yet inside that trifle lives a whole anatomy of modern romantic cowardice. So let’s take it apart, gently, the way you’d lift a sleeping cat off a clean jumper.
A Small Object With a Big Problem
Every great pop song needs a prop. Chuck Berry had his Cadillac, Dylan had his tambourine man, and Malcolm Todd has a pair of earrings. The beauty of the thing is how little it asks of you. Nobody dies, nobody cheats, nobody gets shipped off to war. A man simply leaves something behind in a lover’s bed and then freezes at the prospect of mentioning it.
Todd has described the track as a stroll through his own head while he tries to reach somebody he has lost touch with, and that’s the key to the whole business. The earrings are an excuse, a perfectly respectable reason to send a message, which is exactly what makes the silence so damning. If you’ve got a legitimate pretext to get in touch and you still can’t do it, then the problem was never logistics. You’d simply rather sit in the wreckage of a half-finished romance than risk the small, sharp humiliation of an awkward text. The narrator knows this. So does everybody listening, which is why it stings.
Who’s Talking to Whom
One of the cleverest tricks in the song is its point of view. For most of its length Todd sings in the second person, addressing a “you” as though a sardonic friend were reading your own habits back to you across a pub table. It has the tone of an intervention conducted by somebody who’s just as guilty as the patient. Then, in the bridge, the device collapses. Todd announces his own feelings in the voice of a tabloid newsboy, breaking the story that Malcolm is feeling things and can’t climb out of them. It’s funny, it’s self-mocking, and it’s also a small act of surrender. The detached observer was the narrator all along.
That marriage of irony and sincerity is the native tongue of bedroom pop, and Todd speaks it fluently. He produced the song with his longtime collaborator Charlie Ziman, and he has reportedly said he wrote it once he was already somewhat over the breakup, which would explain the crooked smile in the writing. This isn’t a man bleeding on the carpet. It’s a man who has recovered enough to laugh at his own paralysis, though not enough to pretend it never happened.
Why It Sounds the Way It Does
Lyrics alone don’t explain why the song works, since plenty of people have written about being a coward in love. The sound does a great deal of the heavy lifting. The track runs to barely two and a half minutes, and the production has a deliberately homemade feel: nasal keyboards, loose and slightly sloppy drums, and vocals stacked on top of one another until Todd sounds like a small committee of himself. The New York Times heard a family resemblance to Steve Lacy’s “Bad Habit”, and you can see what they mean, with that same unhurried slouch and that same sweetness with a wry curl on it.
The sloppiness isn’t a flaw. It’s the point. A glossy, razor-sharp production would have made the narrator sound as though he had his act together, and the whole premise is that he doesn’t. Instead the track wobbles along like a man pacing his flat at two in the morning, composing texts he’ll never send. Near the end the music dissolves into a fuzzy, psychedelic collage, and then Todd signs off with a sheepish aside to the listener about hoping you enjoy the mixtape. It’s a wonderfully awkward exit. Having bared his soul, he promptly tries to change the subject, which is precisely what people do in real life. Even the song’s brevity feels like character: it says its piece, gets embarrassed and leaves before anybody can ask a follow-up question.
Heartbreak Without the Fireworks
Pop has always been fond of a spectacular breakup. The old bluesmen, bless them, never had to contend with the group chat. Their women left on the midnight train, and the men responded by drinking, cursing and, in a few memorable cases, shooting somebody. Heartbreak had weather, thunder and a body count.
Todd’s version is far quieter and, I’d argue, far more recognisable. Nobody has been wronged, exactly. Nobody has stormed out. The thing between these two people simply dissolves in a solution of avoidance, one unanswered message at a time, until there’s no relationship left to rescue. There’s no villain in the song, only a bloke with a very small problem that has swollen, through neglect, into a very large one. That’s how most modern romances actually end: not with a bang or a whimper, but with a seen receipt and a shrug.
The Slow Road to Stardom
The commercial story is the sort of thing that makes record executives weep into their espresso. “Earrings” opened Todd’s 2024 mixtape Sweet Boy, his major-label debut on Columbia, and for a good while it was simply an excellent album track. Then TikTok did what TikTok does. In 2026 the song surged, Columbia sent it to American pop radio that April, it climbed into the top twenty of the Billboard Hot 100, and it went platinum in several countries. His sister, the singer Audrey Hobert, even covered it on Australia’s triple j.
Why this song, and why then? My theory is that it says out loud what a great many people do in silence. In an age of read receipts and typing bubbles, everybody has an unsent message sitting in their drafts like a loaded revolver. Todd found a joke and a melody that let people admit it. There’s relief in hearing your own cowardice sung back to you in such a sweet, woozy voice. It turns shame into a singalong, which is a very old pop trick and still a very good one.
The Last Word
“Earrings” is a song about the things we leave behind and the nerve it takes to go back for them. Malcolm Todd takes a trinket, a bed and a text message that never gets sent, and spins them into something funny, rueful and oddly tender. It doesn’t solve the problem it describes, and it’s far too wise to try. What it offers instead is company. If you’ve ever hovered over the send button until the moment passed, here’s a catchy little record to tell you that you’re not alone, and that the earrings, wherever they’ve ended up, can probably wait. Not bad going for two and a half minutes and a single misplaced accessory.