Some songs sound like a party. “We Are Young” sounds like the morning after the night before, sung while you are still a bit drunk. Released in 2011 by the New York trio Fun., with Janelle Monáe guesting on vocals, it began as a modest single and ended up spending six weeks at number one in America, winning a Grammy for Song of the Year and soundtracking a thousand graduation montages. Yet underneath that triumphant chorus lies a small, rather sad story about an apology that might not be accepted. It is a song about youth, and a song about regret, and it is cleverer than its reputation suggests.
An Apology in a Bar
Start with the first verse, because it is wonderfully small. A man is trying to patch up a relationship, offering his lover an apology, while a friend has slipped away and is spending the evening in a bathroom, getting dangerously high. It is not exactly the stuff of anthems. The narrator seems to have burned some bridges, and the opening is full of awkwardness, a shaky attempt to say sorry in the middle of a noisy room. If you listen carefully, the first half of the song is a reconciliation in progress, a request for another chance made with more hope than confidence. It is a reminder that the grandest anthems often begin with the smallest, most embarrassing human moments.
Then the song does something clever. The private moment widens into a general one. The narrator turns from the person he wants to mend things with to the whole room and, by extension, to everyone who has ever been young and reckless. The chorus arrives like a sunrise, a rousing declaration that tonight is the night to set the world alight. Notice, though, that the exuberance is partly a defence mechanism. People shout loudest when they are most afraid, and there is a faint note of desperation in the way the narrator insists on youth, as if repeating it might hold off the clock.
Three Bandmates and a Hip-Hop Producer
The song was written by Fun.’s three members, singer Nate Ruess, guitarist Jack Antonoff and multi-instrumentalist Andrew Dost, together with producer Jeff Bhasker. All had come from other bands: Ruess from the theatrical pop group The Format, Antonoff from the New Jersey indie outfit Steel Train, and Dost from the experimental Anathallo. Bhasker was the outsider, a keyboard player and producer who had made his name working with hip-hop giants, co-writing for the likes of Kanye West and Jay-Z. It was an unusual combination, and a fruitful one. Fun. brought the big theatrical melodies. Bhasker brought a drum sound you could march to.
A piano and a martial beat open the track, giving it the feel of a hymn rather than a rock song. Then the voices pile in. Ruess has a ludicrously powerful tenor, theatrical and slightly nasal, in the tradition of Freddie Mercury and the Broadway stage, and the big gang-vocal chorus has the same communal pull as a football chant. Monáe appears in the bridge like a guest star at a surprise party, adding gravitas and a touch of soul. The production is clean and big and very modern, with enough hip-hop thump to keep the grand gestures grounded. The result is theatre for the iPod generation. It could easily have tipped into bombast, but the sincerity of the performance keeps it honest, and the slight roughness around the edges of the vocals reminds you that real people are singing.
How a Car Commercial Made a Number One
For all its virtues, “We Are Young” was no immediate smash. The single came out in September 2011 and rumbled along quietly until a Chevrolet commercial aired during the Super Bowl in February 2012. Suddenly tens of millions of viewers heard that thunderous chorus at once, and the song rocketed up the charts. A cover version on the television series Glee helped keep the momentum going. By the spring it had reached number one on the Billboard Hot 100, where it stayed for six weeks. The commercial did not invent the song’s appeal, but it did prove that a good chorus is a powerful weapon when you give it a big enough audience.
There is something poetic about the way it happened. A song about youthful abandon was launched by an advertisement for a car, which is about as modern a form of fame as you can imagine. Purists grumbled, as purists always do. But the truth is that the song had been waiting for exactly this kind of moment, a communal event where millions of people experience the same sound together. It is hard to be cynical about a chorus that unites a nation of couch-bound football fans in a shared sing-along, even if the brand behind it is selling hatchbacks.
What It Really Means
So is it a celebration or a lament? Both, and that is the point. The song captures the paradox of being young: you feel invincible and terrified at the same time. The narrator is trying to hold on to a moment, aware on some level that moments cannot be held. The chorus is a toast, but it is also a plea. It says that tonight is the night to feel young, which quietly implies that one day it will not be. Beneath the thumping drums and the glorious melody is a wistfulness that makes the whole thing more affecting than a straightforward party anthem. Nobody sings about youth quite so loudly unless they are slightly scared of losing it. It is a rare modern anthem that people sing without embarrassment at weddings, at funerals and in the back of taxis.
The song’s success was enormous and well deserved. It won Song of the Year at the 2013 Grammy Awards, and Fun. took the Best New Artist prize as well. Antonoff, who has since become one of the most in-demand producers in pop, went on to work with Taylor Swift, Lorde and Lana Del Rey, among many others, and Ruess has had a quieter, but equally interesting, solo career. Looking back, “We Are Young” feels like the starting gun for a whole era of big, cinematic, earnestly emotional pop. It dared to be sincere at a time when irony was the default, and sincerity, as it turns out, travels very well.
The Last Word
At bottom, “We Are Young” is about the strange, fleeting power of a night when anything seems possible. It acknowledges the mess, the mistakes and the apologies, and it chooses, nonetheless, to sing. The chorus does not argue that youth lasts forever. It simply insists that for this moment, in this room, with these people, life is worth celebrating. That is a modest philosophy, and a wise one. Play it at the end of a long evening, with the lights low and your friends close, and you will understand why a song about a drunken apology became an anthem for millions. Some nights deserve a proper soundtrack.