For most of their early career, Coldplay were accused of being too nice. Their songs were pretty, their singer was earnest, and critics complained that nobody in the band had ever been properly upset about anything. Then, in the summer of 2008, they released “Viva la Vida”, a song with pounding timpani, a swirling string section and a narrator who has just been overthrown. It reached number one in both Britain and America, the first time the band had managed either, and it later won the Grammy for Song of the Year. The title means long live life, and the story is about the end of a reign. How did the politest band in the world end up singing about revolution?
A King With No Kingdom
The narrator is a deposed ruler looking back. He remembers what it was like to give an order and watch armies move, to hear a crowd shout his name and to believe the whole world had been arranged for him. Now he is alone. He lives in the streets he once owned, sweeping them like a servant, and he hears church bells and the singing of ancient soldiers in the distance. He knows that his enemies understood something about him that he never did. In the final turn, he suggests that even Saint Peter, the keeper of the gates of heaven, will not call his name.
What makes the song work is that the king is neither a monster nor a martyr. He is a man discovering how thin his power really was. A crown, after all, is a kind of agreement. People obey because they believe the others will obey too, and when that belief breaks, the throne turns out to be a chair. The lyric never names a country or a century. It could be Paris in 1789, Rome at the end of its empire, or any office, family or company where somebody mistook other people’s loyalty for his own strength. The album cover points to France, since it borrows Eugène Delacroix’s painting of the revolution with the title scrawled across it, but the song keeps its borders vague on purpose.
A Title Borrowed from a Painter
The phrase came from somewhere unexpected. Chris Martin was visiting the Frida Kahlo museum in Mexico when he saw one of her last paintings, a still life of watermelons with the words Viva la Vida inscribed on the fruit. He liked the title, and Martin keeps a running list of phrases he thinks might someday fit a song, so he wrote it down. It took a while to find a home.
Kahlo’s life gives the words a strange weight. She endured polio as a child, a bus accident that shattered her spine, and decades of chronic pain, and still her final painting ended with a cheer for life. Martin has talked about admiring that strength. It is a small, brilliant irony that the song takes this affirmation as its name and then fills itself with a story of defeat. The king has lost everything, and yet the title is a toast. You can read it as a bitter joke or as a quiet consolation. Perhaps the point is that you only learn how to say it after you have lost what you thought mattered.
Eno, Strings and a Different Coldplay
The sound of the record was a deliberate break. For their first three albums the band had worked in a familiar mold of piano, guitar and aching falsetto, a style they themselves called a trilogy. For this one they brought in Brian Eno, the producer who had helped make U2’s biggest records sound like cathedrals, along with Markus Dravs, Rik Simpson and Jon Hopkins. Eno encouraged them to experiment, and it shows. The song is driven by a repeated string figure, played by Davide Rossi, and a percussion part that sounds like a distant march. There is no great guitar solo, and no obvious star turn.
One Los Angeles Times critic compared the strings to the Beatles and the slow build to U2, a mix that sums up the song’s ambition. It wants to be both intimate and enormous. Martin’s voice stays close to the microphone while the arrangement grows around it, and the effect is a little like watching a man talk quietly in the middle of a parade. The drama comes from the contrast. A weaker band would have turned a deposed king into a bellow. Coldplay let him sound tired, almost relieved, and that is much more unsettling.
The Accusation and the Awards
Success brought trouble. In December 2008 the guitarist Joe Satriani filed a lawsuit claiming that the song borrowed substantial portions of his instrumental “If I Could Fly”. The band denied it, and the dispute was eventually resolved away from the public eye. Plagiarism cases are common whenever a record becomes enormous, and the more interesting point is how much the song had already conquered by then. Driven by digital sales, it hit number one on the Billboard Hot 100 and on the UK chart.
At the Grammy Awards in February 2009, Coldplay won three trophies: Song of the Year for “Viva la Vida”, Best Rock Album for the record it came from, and Best Pop Performance by a Duo or Group. Martin joked from the stage that they were not the heaviest of rock bands. In the years since, the song has accumulated billions of streams and become one of the most-played pieces of music of its era.
Who Is the King?
Martin has been fairly vague about whether the lyric points to any single event, and that vagueness has fed endless speculation. Some listeners hear a comment on celebrity, on how fast an adored figure can fall. Some hear a religious crisis, the loss of faith that comes when the old certainties stop working. Others hear the band themselves, a group that had been crowned the world’s most reliable stadium act and was trying to take apart its own formula. All of these readings are plausible, and the song encourages them.
A song about a king is always also a song about the people who made him one. The audience that sings along is the crowd in the story, and every voice in a stadium chorus is, in a sense, a citizen who might still decide to withdraw consent. That is a strange thing to ask forty thousand people to do while holding up their phones, and the band surely knew it.
What Lasts
“Viva la Vida” survives because it sounds like victory and tells the truth about loss. The tune is bright and the story is bleak, and the clash gives the record a kind of dignity. It reminds us that power is borrowed and that the things we most trust can vanish overnight. It also suggests, through its title, that the correct response is not despair. When the crown is gone, there is still the morning, the street and the small, stubborn fact of being alive. Long live that. Stadium crowds still sing it back to the stage, and for four minutes the fallen king is forgiven by the very people who unseated him.