The Meaning of “Sunflower” by Post Malone

Written by James Hayes

It would be easy to dismiss “Sunflower” as a pleasant piece of studio engineering: a soft-focus duet between two of pop’s most relaxed voices, tucked into the soundtrack of an animated superhero film. It lasts under three minutes, has no big chorus drama, and sounds as though it was recorded while lying on a sofa. And yet it reached number one in America, later hit double-diamond certification, and turned out to be oddly hard to pin down. Is it a love song? A complaint? A confession? The answer, as with most things that sound this effortless, is that it is a bit of all three, and rather more sorrowful than it first lets on.

A superhero song with no superhero in it

Post Malone and Swae Lee released “Sunflower” in October 2018 as the second single from the soundtrack to Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse, a film that opened in December and quickly became a critical favourite. Its young hero, Miles Morales, is a teenager trying to work out who he is, and the picture runs on a restless, youthful, slightly melancholy energy. The song fits that mood perfectly. What it does not do is mention anything about spiders, secret identities or saving New York. It is a song about a girl.

That distinction matters. Plenty of soundtrack singles strain to echo the plot of the film they serve, and the results tend to be clumsy. This one simply exists alongside it, a piece of ordinary adolescent longing floating through a world of extraordinary events. It was previewed on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon before the film opened and later turned up on Post Malone’s third album, Hollywood’s Bleeding, where it sat comfortably among his other songs about being unlucky in love.

Six writers and a very small song

The credits run long. Six people share the writing: Austin Post, who is Post Malone, Khalif Brown, who is Swae Lee, the producers Louis Bell and Carter Lang, and two other collaborators, Billy Walsh and Carl Rosen. Bell was already Post Malone’s closest creative partner, the man behind much of his sound, while Lang had worked with artists such as SZA and Rihanna. Between them they built something remarkably spare.

Six writers is not a lot by the standards of late-2010s chart pop, where credit lists could rival film crews, and the song’s economy shows. At two minutes and thirty-eight seconds it does not outstay its welcome. There is a plain verse, a plain hook, and hardly any embellishment, as if the team had agreed that anything extra would spoil the atmosphere. It is a lesson in what can be achieved by taking things away, and in this case what remained was almost embarrassingly catchy.

Who is the sunflower?

Swae Lee takes the first verse and Post Malone the second, and both describe a romantic situation that never quite resolves. The woman at the centre is attractive, magnetic and not entirely dependable. Each singer seems captivated and a little exasperated at the same time. Whether they are describing the same person is left to the listener, and one critic memorably observed that they may be singing about ill-defined relationships, or possibly the same ill-defined relationship.

The title gives us a clue and then declines to explain it. Sunflowers are famous for their devotion to light: young plants follow the sun across the sky, turning their heads from east to west as the day goes by. So who is the flower and who is the sun? Perhaps she is the sunflower, bright and upright and beautiful. Perhaps the singer is, trailing after someone he cannot hold. The song gives us both pictures, and neither feels complete without the other, which is a rather good description of how it feels to be in love with the wrong person.

There is also a suspicion that the song is more honest about self-deception than it appears. Both singers insist they are handling things, that they are cool, that they can wait; both betray, in small ways, that they are doing nothing of the kind. The coolness is a performance, a mask worn over some fairly ordinary anxieties. A film about a boy learning to wear a mask turns out, almost accidentally, to have found its ideal anthem.

The sound of nothing happening

The production is built around space. A hazy synth line floats above a lazy beat, a bassline drifts rather than drives, and the whole arrangement seems to hover a few inches above the ground. Critics have called it dream pop and chillwave, and both labels capture its sleepy, sun-bleached quality. Nothing in it rushes, and nothing in it insists.

That calm sets up a lovely contrast between the voices. Swae Lee glides over the melody in a light, bending lilt, as though singing were less effort than talking. Post Malone, by contrast, comes in with a rough-edged drawl that sounds like it has been up all night. Together they create something like the tone of two friends comparing notes on the same heartbreak: one wistful, one rueful, neither interested in shouting about it. It is the sonic equivalent of leaving a message unread, a kind of studied casualness that conceals a great deal of feeling.

It is also worth noting how unfussy the recording is. There are no pyrotechnics, no big key change, no moment where the song stops to show off. Producers call that restraint; listeners tend to feel it as warmth. The song never tries to impress you, and so it never gives you anything to resist.

A number one for the streaming age

In January 2019, “Sunflower” reached the top of the Billboard Hot 100. It was Post Malone’s third number one and Swae Lee’s first as a solo credit, and it was the first soundtrack song to top the chart since Justin Timberlake’s “Can’t Stop the Feeling!” It had arrived on the chart at number nine, a modest opening, and climbed steadily as streaming caught up with the radio. Bell, meanwhile, had now been a writer and producer on consecutive chart-toppers, a feat that had not been managed for years.

The song’s success says something about the way we listen now. “Sunflower” is mood music in the truest sense, designed to slide into a playlist and make an afternoon feel softer. That might sound like a criticism, but it is not meant as one. There is real craft in making something that asks so little of a listener and gives so much back, and the craft is easy to miss precisely because it is so well hidden. Its popularity was no accident. It simply fit the way people wanted to feel.

Still turning toward the light

So what does “Sunflower” mean? Perhaps only this: that wanting somebody can feel like the most natural thing in the world and still leave you unsure where you stand. The song never resolves its romance, and it never needs to. It sits in the pleasant, uneasy middle, in the hours after a message has been sent and before an answer arrives. Like the plant it is named for, it keeps its face turned toward something it can never quite reach, and somehow that restless beauty is what has kept people listening. It is a small song, and a very good one, and it knows better than to pretend otherwise.