The Meaning of “Fireflies” by Owl City

Written by James Hayes

Some songs arrive with a sneer already waiting for them. “Fireflies” was one of them: a glittering slab of synth-pop by a young man from Minnesota who sang as though he were apologising for the noise, released in the summer of 2009 and, inconveniently for the sneerers, adored by almost everyone. It went to number one in America and Britain, and critics have been trying to explain why ever since. The easy answer is that it is cute. The better answer is that it is about something rather lonely: a person who cannot sleep, a house full of people who can, and a pop song built to keep the dark company.

A basement, a MicroKorg and a very long night

Adam Young was in his early twenties when he wrote “Fireflies”, still living with his parents in Owatonna, Minnesota, and working a warehouse job that involved loading Coca-Cola trucks. The hours left him wired. He would come home wide awake, unable to settle, and rather than stare at the ceiling he went down to the basement and made music instead. By his own account, the song began at around two in the morning, with a small synthesiser balanced on his lap and a head full of the fireflies he had watched appear at dusk during a recent trip to Iowa.

That is more or less the whole origin story, and it is more charming for being so modest. Young has said the connection between insomnia and lightning bugs simply happened, and that the song practically wrote itself. For a while it was even called “Back to Bed”. He once described it as a little song about bugs and not being able to fall asleep, which is either admirable honesty or a very effective piece of misdirection, because the song is not quite as small as that description suggests.

What the words are actually doing

Read the lyrics on paper and what you get is a dream sequence rather than a story. The narrator is awake in the small hours, wishing the Earth would turn more slowly so that the night might stretch out and the morning stay politely away. Around him, the room fills with glowing insects that behave less like pests than like friends, handing out affection by the thousand. At one point he announces that he would rather remain conscious inside his own dream, a thought that muddles waking and sleeping so thoroughly it stops mattering which one he is in.

This is the trick at the heart of it. A song about sleeplessness would normally be grey and fretful, all circles under the eyes. Young makes his insomnia luminous. The fireflies are what a restless mind does with the hours nobody else wants: it turns them into somewhere to walk around. The wistfulness is real, though. Everything beautiful in the song happens at the expense of company, and the narrator seems perfectly aware of it. His dreams, he tells us, are too big for the room they are in, which is a lovely thing to feel and an exhausting thing to live with at three in the morning.

Bright on the surface, sad underneath

The sound does a great deal of the emotional work. Young built the track around a bleepy, bouncing synth line and a vocal so soft it barely seems to take up space, then let a cello, played by Phil Peterson, warm the edges. Matthew Thiessen of Relient K, a friend, co-produced the song and sings backing vocals, which gives the chorus a sunnier lift than a lone bedroom voice could manage. Everything is major-key and sparkly, the musical equivalent of a night-light left on in the hallway.

Inevitably, plenty of listeners heard The Postal Service in it. The comparison to Ben Gibbard’s gentle electronic indie-pop was not unfair, whatever Young said about never meaning to copy anyone, but Gibbard’s records tend to carry a bruise. Owl City is more open-faced. The music video, directed by Steve Hoover, leans into that openness: Young plays a small organ in a bedroom full of toys that come to life after dark, as though the whole song were a nursery rhyme for adults who never quite got round to sleeping. It is the nearest the song comes to a literal picture of its own mood, a place where the night belongs to whoever is still awake.

An accidental number one

Nobody expected much. His manager has said the track was never intended as a single, and Young himself was not convinced it was a hit. It debuted on the Billboard Hot 100 in early September 2009 at number 97, then climbed for ten weeks before reaching the top, where it sat for two non-consecutive spells. It topped the British chart as well. A bedroom project had become a global pop event, a few years before bedroom pop turned into a genre label with its own playlists.

The backlash was predictable. Critics called it twee, derivative, a novelty. What they were mostly reacting to, I think, was sincerity. Young’s lyrics do not hedge. There is no irony shield, no wink to say he knows how this sounds. In 2009, with indie culture still fond of a raised eyebrow, that made the song easy to mock. It also made it easy to love, especially if you were fifteen, awake in your own room, and quietly convinced that nobody else on Earth felt like this at two in the morning.

The loneliness you can dance to

If there is a single idea worth carrying away, it is that “Fireflies” is a song about being alone that sounds like a party. The tension between those two things is what has kept it alive for well over a decade. The fireflies are not really insects, or not only. They are proof that something is awake and glowing when the rest of the world has gone dark, a promise that insomnia, for all its misery, comes with company if you look hard enough.

That is also why the song has outlasted its sneerers. Plenty of louder, cooler records from 2009 have settled into period pieces. This one still gets played at weddings, in bedrooms and in the back seats of cars, because the feeling it describes never went out of date. Anyone who has lain awake counting the hours knows the hope buried inside it: that the night will end, and that before it does, it might turn out to be a little bit magical.

Why it still glows

Strip away the memes and the backlash and “Fireflies” is a very simple piece of writing about a very ordinary problem. A young man cannot sleep, so he builds a small world out of light and sound and lets the rest of us in. That generosity is what has kept it going. It does not ask you to decode anything or admire its cleverness; it simply keeps you company until morning. Adam Young may never have meant it to be more than a song about bugs and sleeplessness. But the best pop songs often mean more than their makers intend, and this one, flickering softly in the dark, still does exactly that.