The Meaning of “Heathens” by Twenty One Pilots

Written by James Hayes

Few pop songs have had such an awkward job description as “Heathens” by Twenty One Pilots. Attached to the soundtrack of a film about incarcerated supervillains, it had to sound menacing enough to sit alongside Harley Quinn and her pals while remaining recognisably the work of a duo better known for earnest introspection and rap-rock theatrics. It managed both, and then some, climbing to number two on the American chart. But the song is a good deal more peculiar than its blockbuster origins suggest. Beneath the brooding atmosphere lies a rather unexpected message about outsiders, newcomers and the strange politics of fandom. Let us take a closer look at what Tyler Joseph is really warning us about.

A Villain’s Soundtrack With a Secret Agenda

The song’s origins are straightforward enough. Twenty One Pilots, a duo from Columbus, Ohio, made up of singer and multi-instrumentalist Tyler Joseph and drummer Josh Dun, were riding high after the success of their 2015 album Blurryface when “Heathens” appeared in June 2016 as the lead single from the soundtrack to Suicide Squad. Joseph wrote it and produced it with Mike Elizondo, and the accompanying video places the pair inside the fictional prison of Belle Reve, surrounded by the film’s rogues’ gallery. Joseph has said that the themes of the movie sparked the opening ideas, but that as the lyrics came together he realised the song was something more personal. In other words, a track designed to advertise a comic-book blockbuster turned into a Twenty One Pilots song with a Twenty One Pilots preoccupation.

That preoccupation, as it happens, is community, and the dangers that come with it. Twenty One Pilots have one of the most devoted fan bases in modern rock, a self-styled gang known as the Skeleton Clique, and by 2016 that gang was being joined by thousands of curious newcomers drawn in by radio hits. Many fans and commentators have read “Heathens” as Joseph’s attempt to speak to this very situation. The narrator is, in effect, a gatekeeper addressing the newcomers, cautioning them to tread carefully among people who are wary of outsiders. It is a surprising thing to find at the heart of a chart hit, a song that tells most of its own audience that they might not be welcome. One can only imagine what the marketing department made of it.

Who Counts as a Heathen?

The word itself is a gift to anyone who enjoys a little ambiguity. Historically, a heathen is someone who stands outside the dominant religion of a community, an unbeliever or outsider, and Joseph borrows that vocabulary to describe anyone who sits on the margins of a group. The twist is that the song’s narrator claims the label for his own friends, the people he trusts, and treats them as a tribe of the misunderstood. The implication is that the true outsiders are not the ones beyond the walls but the ones inside, the awkward, wounded, suspicious individuals who have found one another and are not eager to see their refuge invaded. It is a defensive stance, but a very human one. That fear is the song’s quiet engine, and it makes every glance feel loaded.

Read this way, the song’s warnings take on a gently comic quality. The narrator advises the newcomer that he should have stayed away, that he has stumbled into a room where everyone is on edge, and that the people inside have little patience for pretenders. There is a hint of the schoolyard in all this, of cliques guarding their territory and sizing up the new arrival, yet Joseph delivers it with such solemnity that it never tips into parody. Nor is the song merely hostile. Its refrain suggests that the newcomer might, in the end, turn out to be one of the tribe after all, which is the sort of ambiguity that separates a thoughtful lyric from a mere insult. The gate, it seems, is locked but not welded shut.

A Menacing Lullaby

Musically, “Heathens” is a study in controlled unease. It is built on a slow, hip-hop-flavoured beat and a mournful piano figure, with Joseph’s voice kept low and almost conversational, as though he were speaking through a half-open door. The song sits in a minor key at a stately tempo, and the sparse arrangement leaves plenty of room for silence, which is where much of the tension lives. A ghostly, disembodied voice murmurs in the background like a prison guard making rounds, adding to the sense that something is being watched, assessed and slowly closed in on. It is the kind of production that makes you lower your own voice without noticing, and it suits the paranoia of the words perfectly.

What is striking is how little the song needs to do to unsettle. Dun’s drumming, which can be thunderous elsewhere in the band’s catalogue, is held firmly in check, tapping out a measured pulse rather than a rampage. Joseph’s vocal delivery moves between a half-rapped, half-murmured verse and a chorus that is almost lullaby-like in its simplicity, and the contrast between the soothing melody and the menacing sentiment is where the song gets its sting. A threat whispered, after all, is always more convincing than one shouted. By the time the track reaches its final moments, the listener has been lulled into a kind of uneasy compliance, which is surely the point. It is pop music as a dimly lit corridor, and you walk down it willingly.

Why It Struck Such a Chord

Part of the reason “Heathens” connected so widely is that it works on at least two levels. For the casual listener, it is a moody, atmospheric rock-rap hybrid that happens to fit the world of comic-book villains rather neatly. For those who dig a little deeper, it is a meditation on belonging and exclusion, on the odd ways in which groups form identities around shared wounds and then defend them with surprising ferocity. Both interpretations are valid, and they are not mutually exclusive. The villains of Suicide Squad are, after all, the ultimate outsiders, a gang of misfits thrown together and treated with suspicion by the rest of the world, which makes the song an unexpectedly good fit. It is a rare example of a soundtrack song that sounds as though it belongs entirely to its creators.

The public response left little doubt. The track reached number two on the American Billboard Hot 100, matching the peak of the duo’s earlier hit “Stressed Out”, and it went on to pick up three Grammy nominations. For a song that is, in essence, a warning to keep out, it let in an awful lot of people. That irony has not gone unnoticed, and the band, who have long cultivated a sense of community that is both fiercely loyal and, in theory, open to all, seem comfortable with it. Perhaps that is the real message buried in the song: the people who feel like outsiders are rarely as exclusive as they pretend, and the doors they claim to guard are usually waiting for someone to knock.

Final Thoughts

In the end, “Heathens” succeeds because it turns a potential disadvantage into an asset. Handed a film about villains, Tyler Joseph instead wrote about the rest of us, the odd, wary souls who build little communities and then worry about who might wander in. The sparse, haunting production lends the idea an air of genuine menace, while the lyric’s ambiguity leaves room for every listener to decide which side of the door they are standing on. It is smart, strange and surprisingly tender beneath its scowl. Few blockbuster tie-ins can claim to have said anything at all about human nature, and fewer still manage to do so in a little over three minutes.